| | Butler | New Albany |
|---|
| 106 Layton Combs (11) | 113 Willem Busch (9) |
| 113 Lucas Carroll (10) | 113 Austin Pfeifer (9) |
| 120 Tristin Falcione (10) | 120 Tristan Nguyen (9) |
| 126 Keegan Hoop (11) | 120 James Harney (9) |
| 132 Yhantg Irwin (10) | 126 Jake Shirck (9) |
| 138 Louden Maxwell (12) | 138 Logan George (10) |
| 144 Bryce Hatfield (12) | 144 Will Meisner (9) |
| 150 Evan Lucario (10) | 150 Max Meisner (11) |
| 157 Brody Rosenkranz (12) | 157 Kyle Kochedoerfer (9) |
| 165 Braylen Crump (12) | 157 Drake Farrar (12) |
| 175 Jace Love (10) | 165 Anderson Rice (11) |
| 190 Tristan Tipton (11) | 165 Ryan Bose (9) |
| 190 James Hodge (12) | 175 Simon Lenhart (11) |
| 215 Cooper Pion (12) | 190 Henry Dunn (11) |
| 285 Seth Gibson (12) | 190 Christopher Billups (10) |
| 285 Jackson Brock (11) | 215 Hunter Howard (11) |
| 215 John Roth (9) |
| 215 Beckett McMullin (9) |
| 285 John Buckner (12) |